Jump to content

Which comes first? Panels or boards?


m00dawg

Recommended Posts

I am about 75% of the way done with my control surface board wiring. I already have the positions of the knobs and stuff and, as best as I can tell, things appear to line up with my panel, both with measuring and eyeballing (by printing both out and comparing them on top of each other). The panel is going to run probably about $250 from FrontPanel Express and I am trying to figure out how best to approach things.

So I'm curious what some of you custom control surface peeps do? Do you prototype your front panel and, if so, how exactly do you do that? I thought about cardboard, but I'm not sure how accurate I can be while still getting a good measurement and letting my buttons function as they should.

I would actually rather buy the panel and hope :) That way I can mount the control boards as I finish them, have a visual stimulus I can work towards, and if I mess up a measurement, I can remake a control board cheaper than having to make a whole new panel.

Advice is much appreciated as I'm a bit stumped :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I typically try to import/export as much as possible between the apps (in my case inkscape, eagle and fpd) :) That way you can easily check if the stuff you made in X actually matches what you have in Y. Obviously you wanna have the parts beforehand so you can crosscheck dimensions with the datasheets. Worked flawlessly so far for me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hah good call on comparing datasheet measurements :) Just realized the buttons I was going to get might flare too much if they stick out too far from the control surface.

The biggest issue I am concerned about is missing a measurement between the control surface board and front panel (so a button is off by some amount). So far, everything has lined up perfectly when comparing print-outs on top of each other. But, man, dropping $250 on a panel makes me nervous :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I compare my KiCAD files with my frontpanel design. I also put loads of measurements both on my PCB design and frontpanel design and print them from time to time.

I also make an MDF wood frontpanel(thin wood), this costs me a few Euro's, and that way I am sure that the frontpanel design fits the PCB. This also rules out stupid mistakes or things that I just forgot, misplaced,...

cheers Jef

Link to comment
Share on other sites

How do you make your wood panel? Just by hand?

MOODOG,

I have tried making panels first and then making the PCB later and that never works, the easiest way for me is to do my Control Surface in Eagle and then export an image from Eagle and bring it into adobe illustrator which is where I layout my front panel, I use the image that i exported from eagle as a background for my illustrator layout so i just draw my cutlines for the front panel right over top of the component outlines from the eagle image.

Why don't you prototype your frontpanel with laser-cut acrylic from ponoko? It will cost very little, and if you're happy with the result, then you can be confident when you drop $250 on the nice metal panel from FPE.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ah good idea! I wonder if FPE lets you put images in the background...hmm... I had originally written of Pokono due to not being able to export my panel from FPE, but I now see there are options to do that, so yeah that's an option I'll have to consider!

Might actually even look cooler in acrylic anyway, although I'm guessing I can't do fancy things like blind threaded holes and such.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

*WOW* So apparently my 3U panel is only about $40.00 US to make via Ponoko. That doesn't include any engraving or the screw holes I will need to use (instead of the hidden screw holes I had on my aluminum version) but even the thickness is what I wanted (3mm). I'll have to figure out how to constrain my sizes a bit - I had to use the largest size available from Ponoko to fit my 3U panel so I'll have to look into that further. It also took a bit of work to get it from Front Panel, mostly due to having to change line colors and widths. I haven't tried lettering yet (I just exported the cuts).

But I think this could be a very viable option, thanks for the idea, sidmonster!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah,

I changed the frontpanel layout on my MBSID a few times and it only cost me about $30.00 each time to have ponoko cut it. Now that I've finally settled on a design and used it comfortably for a month, I am ready to have it machined out of aluminum. The easiest way is to export a .svg from FPE and import it into illustrator or inkscape to change the line weights for ponoko.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

when i do my caseworks and front panels i work off the 2.54mm grid from the pad boards i prototype on. Then I try and use eagle, give the files to nils so he can have a good laugh and correct them where needed (everywhere) i then save a copy of hem as a dxf for the centre points of everything. I then load this into solidworks and check it against my case schematic and then adjust if needed. Works everytime for me, this is how i did the bpm casework and the humon casework.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You save a copy of your board layouts as DXF? How do you do that exactly? I didn't see an option for that in Eagle, but man being able ot see the panel on top of the boards would be a huge help. Right now, I just print them out and hold both up to a light source ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For my circle sequencer project I had sketched out the panel first using the drawing tools in MS Word. Then I designed the board using Eagle. When I created the footprint for the pushbuttons, I added an extra 1/16" hole right in the middle of the component:

I then clamped the unpopulated circuit board to the back of the panel and drilled through each hole with a 1/16" bit. I removed the panel, then enlarged each hole using a stepped drill bit.

I know this isn't exactly what you're talking about, since this is a homebrew panel, but ... for this project I used the board as a stencil to cut the panel.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

forgot to add, one of the biggest helps as well is i use acetate as well, if im checking the casework against component positions i print each one to acetate sheets and then everlay. examples in my bpm thread.

Man I'm trying to find that thread but I must be really bad at searching :) Happen to have a link?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Indeed it probably won't be thick enough to handle it - the chassis is entirely supported by the front panel. I could probably have it sit on my mic-amp or flip my shelf over and have it sit on that, but I'll probably just leave it out of the rack - I'll have to be adding boards and things to it and working on the internal layout anyway.

Turns out it will be more like $60 after engraving work and the additional mounting holes but that's still pretty dern cheap!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...